江苏龙网

  1. 首页 > 生活 > >

为何豆瓣上对《Boyhood》的评价超高，自己看了却没啥特殊感觉

For every movie on Earth, there are haters that would rate it a 1/10. This is true for every movie out there. There are people who hated Titanic, Dark Knight, Shawshank Redemption, and Godfather. No movie has ever gone perfect with every viewer. For every movie that has a 8.5+ score on imdb, there are people shouting WTF at the final rating.I feel that nowadays there\u0026#39;s too much pressure on conformity. People are starting to feel obligated to like or dislike a movie, and that\u0026#39;s just sad. I don\u0026#39;t think it\u0026#39;s right to condemn an opinion or to attack the people who had different viewings. Nobody came to conclusions without reasoning, and every hater had solid reasons to hate a film. Dark Knight was not realistic, Titanic was shallow and cheesy, Shawshank was cliche and bland... When you actually listen to the people, they do have sound reasons for hating the films. You may not agree, but every opinion had a forming process, and you can\u0026#39;t un-form it for them. And in the case of Boyhood, it\u0026#39;s just too obvious. A movie that\u0026#39;s 2.5 hours long with no climax and virtually no plot as well as a set of unmotivated passive lead characters each with loads of personal problems is bound to receive controversy. Some may be able to ignore all the blandness in this film, some may not. For me, this is my ultimate WTF movie. I hated it and I couldn\u0026#39;t believe that there weren\u0026#39;t more people who felt the same way that I did. Moreover I couldn\u0026#39;t believe that people even applauded Linklater\u0026#39;s "effort" in making this movie. This is a super low budget film, he only filmed for 3 days each year, he didn\u0026#39;t even write a script he just asked the lead boy what happened to him each year and made up a script impromptu, and he hired his 8-year-old daughter as the lead female. Does this sound like effort?It\u0026#39;s easy to follow the trend and dis people for liking or disliking certain things, but ultimately it\u0026#39;s just very silly to do so. The adults laugh at the teenagers for following Justin Bieber and One Direction, but before Bieber was Bieber, Aaron Carter was Bieber, and before 1D was 1D, the Backstreet Boys were 1D. Different people are going to have different tastes, and even the same person can develop different tastes over time. No film is going to satisfy every viewer, and I feel that it\u0026#39;s very unfair for the majority to pressure the minority into thinking that their opinion about a certain film is "wrong". After all, it\u0026#39;s just entertainment, and you can\u0026#39;t force anybody into (or out of) liking a show.
■网友
要经过一些年纪，才会感受到这种很平静的感动。其实这个故事很平凡，就像我们每一个人一样，但我们在看的过程中，有的把小男孩当作自己，有的把他当作自己的孩子，都会感受到他父亲、母亲、爷爷奶奶对他的祝福。虽然父亲离婚了，却总是教给他很多的道理，母亲为了这个单亲家庭一直付出了很多，爷爷送给他生日礼物，都代表了平凡生活中的感动。拍的很真实。

■网友
以前答的这是什么。
评价高是有原因的，光是拍摄时间就用了十二年（不是说一直在拍），戏里和戏外的时间线同步，现实主义在这一方面做到了极致，制作上还有很多其他繁琐的事情。但我觉得最重要的还是很多人看到自己的影子，有共鸣，大家如同看见了自己，从一个单纯地小孩，成长为一个怀疑世界的青年，还有一点，时间线正好也在我们现在所处的时代，特别是到移动手机普及后，几乎就和我们现在的生活一样了。


推荐阅读


上一篇：关于GBDT的几个不理解的地方?

下一篇：新手怎样在没有经验的前提下，获取经验